QCS-4
AUGUST 2001
SUPERSEDES
December 1996
GENERAL DYNAMICS
LAND SYSTEMS DIVISION
QUALITY TEST SPECIFICATION
QCS-4
FOR
FIRST ARTICLE APPROVAL
REQUIREMENTS FOR TESTING COMPONENTS
|
QCS-4
AUGUST 2001
SUPERSEDES
December 1996
TABLE OF CONTENTS
l. DEFINITIONS
2. APPLICABLE DOCUMENTS
3. GENERAL BID REQUIREMENTS AND OPTIONS
4. TEST PLAN AND FACILITIES APPROVAL
5. GENERAL SUPPLIER RESPONSIBILITIES
6. TEST SAMPLE
7. TEST SCHEDULE AND START NOTIFICATION
8. TEST MONITORING
9. TEST INCIDENTS/FAILURES
10. FINAL TEST REPORT
11. INVOICE PAYMENT
12. TEST REQUIREMENT FULFILLMENT BY
REPRESENTATIVE PARTS
13. CHANGES TO HARDWARE/PROCESS AFTER FAT
APPROVAL
ATTACHMENTS
A. FLOW CHARTS FOR SUPPLIER RESPONSIBILITY
FOLLOWING A TEST INCIDENT/FAILURE
B. TEST
REPORT PREPARATION, CHECK LIST GUIDE
GENERAL DYNAMICS
LAND SYSTEMS DIVISION
QCS-4
FIRST ARTICLE TEST (F.A.T.)
Requirements for Testing Components
1.0 DEFINITIONS
1.1 Technical Data Package (TDP) Dimensional,
material, process, environmental, inspections and performance requirements as
specified by the drawing, Quality Assurance Requirement (QAR) / Quality
Assurance Provision (QAP) document, GDLS specification and/or military /
commercial specification.
1.2 First Article Sample A production component
(s) submitted as being representative of a specific process using production
tooling, equipment, methods, technique, standards, personnel and controls.
1.3 First Article Approval (F.A.A.) First
Article Approval is defined as the approval of the requirements of 1.4, First
Article Inspection (F.A.I.), and 1.5, First Article Test (F.A.T.).
1.4 First Article Inspection (F.A.I.) Verification
that the First Article samples manufactured using the normal production process
(planning, technical /work instructions, material processing systems and
controls, tools, fixtures, test equipment and personnel proficiency) will
produce a component in compliance with all TDP requirements (such as drawing
dimensional characteristics, material content meet the physical and performance
requirements of the TDP such as drawing dimensional characteristics, material
content, process, capability and performance.
1.5 First Article Test (F.A.T.) Tests conducted
to verify that the First Article samples meet the performance requirements of
the TDP before, during and after all specified environmental and
durability/endurance conditions.
1.5.1 Mini-F.A.T. Reduced scope F.A.T. which
may be used to verify changes to process, material, location, sub-tier
suppliers or design. Normally the test does not consume the component life and
may be shipped upon test approval.
1.6 Test Plan The
document developed by the vendor or subcontracted testing facility that will be
utilized to test a component to the requirements specified in the TDP. The
document shall contain all the applicable test setups, equipment, references to
drawings, etc. required to provide sufficient information of the intended use
of test equipment required when performing the testing of the components to the
requirements of the TDP.
2.0
APPLICABLE DOCUMENTS
2.1 Government Documents
|
MIL-HBK-831
|
Preparation Of Test Reports
|
|
MIL-STD-45662
|
Calibration System
Requirements
|
2.2 GDLS Documents
|
QCS 83-4
|
Supplier Requirements For
Completion of First Article Inspection
|
3.0
GENERAL BID REQUIREMENTS AND OPTIONS
The
bidder shall include the following requirements, as a minimum, with the Request
for Quote (RFQ):
3.1 First Article Test Costs
Individual costs for the entire First Article Test
Program including hardware, fixtures, equipment, test procedure development,
itemized cost by test parameter and test report preparation. These costs shall
be quoted separately from cost of production hardware.
3.1.1 Test Facilities
Facilities
to be utilized in performance of the First Article Test, if known at the time
of the Request For Quote (RFQ) response, shall be identified in the quotation,
giving the facility name, location, contact, and phone number. If the above
information is not known at the time of the RFQ response, it shall be provided
no later than 30 days after receipt of the F.A.T. requirement notification, by
activation of a purchase order line item requiring final test report submission
to GDLS.
3.1.2 GDLS Bid Options
It is GDLS' option to request or obtain competitive
bids for the First Article Test and to have such test performed by another
independent test laboratory. This bidding will be based on geographical
location, scheduling, qualifications, and price. If competitive bids are
requested, a list of approved laboratories will be provided. Should GDLS elect
to remove testing from the assigned supplier paragraph 5.3 applies.
3.2 Disposition of Fixtures and Equipment Procured
for Test Conductance
3.2.1 Identification of Property All test
fixtures, and ancillary equipment (not otherwise required for production and/or
acceptance test), purchased or charged to this contract will be identified and
brass-tagged as the property of the United States Government, and shall be
purchased under a separate GDLS tooling contract.
3.2.2 Test Fixture and Equipment
Maintenance/Calibration Except as otherwise expressly provided under this
document, the Contractor is responsible for the maintenance and calibration of
all inspection and test equipment necessary to assure that supplies and
services conform to contract requirements. Commercial, modified commercial, or
supplier designed inspection or measuring set ups must be capable of repetitive
measurements to an accuracy of 10 percent of the component tolerance. If this
degree of accuracy cannot be obtained, contact Quality Test for disposition.
Calibration of inspection and test equipment shall be in accordance with
MIL-STD-45662. A log of instruments and equipment utilized during the entire
test program shall be maintained and included within the final test report.
3.2.3
Test Equipment Usage
GDLS
furnished test equipment shall be utilized solely for the tests specified in
this contract unless written approval is provided by GDLS.
3.2.4 Test Fixture and Equipment Disposal
This equipment will be sent to GDLS at GDLS request,
when it is no longer necessary for the test program.
4.0
TEST PLAN REVIEW AND FACILITY APPROVAL
4.1 Test Plans
The supplier and/or test laboratory will write test
plans. Questions on or requests for test plan formats should be forwarded to
the Quality Engineering & Test department at the address/phone numbers
shown below:
General Dynamics Land Systems
38500
Mound Road
Sterling
Heights, MI 48310-3200
Attn.:
Quality Engineering & Test Dept., MZ 436-30-44
Telephone:
(810) 825-4530 or 825-4424
FAX:
(810) 825-7414 or 825-7148
4.1.1 Test Plan Review
The supplier shall provide a written test plan to GDLS
a minimum of thirty (30) days prior to the beginning of test. GDLS Quality
Engineering and Test (QE&T) will review to provide exceptions and to ensure
the required Scope of Work (SOW) is included within the test plan. GDLS
QE&T will respond within two (2) weeks of receipt typically.
Upon final agreement, GDLS QE&T will provide
notification to the supplier that the test plan is acceptable by GDLS for use
(See Note 1). No formal Test Plan approval will be provided by GDLS.
Note 1:
The
GDLS review does not exonerate the supplier of the responsibility of testing
and complying with all the requirements of the applicable drawings and
specifications.
4.2 Test Laboratory Approval
The GDLS Quality Test department will suggest
laboratories upon request. It is solely the responsibility of the supplier to
select an acceptable test laboratory that will provide the necessary service to
test to the supplier supplied requirements.
4.2.1 Government Monitoring
Government representatives shall have the right to
monitor any and all facets of the testing. Contracted laboratories must have
Government delegation included in their purchase orders if so directed by the
Government representative. A minimum of one (1) week notification of test start
is to be provided to the Government representative to permit scheduling of
monitoring activities.
4.3 Test Facility
GDLS Quality Test reserves the right to review and
approve all test set-ups, equipment, laboratory procedures, and data sheets
prior to start of testing.
4.3.1 Data Sheet Requirements Data sheets must
consist of the specified resultant values, disposition (passed / failed) and
specification/QAR/QAP paragraph tested unless otherwise authorized by GDLS
Quality Test. Additionally, the data sheets for performance testing shall
contain the following items:
Part
Name and Number
Serial
Number
Date
Of Test
Test
Start and Stop Time
Name
Of Environmental Test
Test
Parameter
Actual
Test Values
Air
Temperature
Barometric
Pressure
Relative
Humidity
Technician/Engineer
Signature
DCAS
stamp (if witnessed)
GDLS
stamp (if witnessed)
4.3.2 Automatic Test Equipment (ATE)
4.3.2.1 ATE Validation
ATE equipment and/or software used to perform testing
will be validated by GDLS prior to its incorporation in the test program. No
change to the ATE hardware and/or software can be made without prior approval
of GDLS. A revalidation of the changes made to either the software and/or
hardware may be required by GDLS.
4.3.2.2 ATE Software
ATE controlling software must be under the
control of a configuration management system, which includes a document number,
revision level, revision date, method of change documentation and change
approval cycle. The software configuration level must be identified in the
final test software report.
4.3.2.3 ATE Data Printout
When actual values are not feasible, pass/fail entries
shall be acceptable when accompanied by GDLS approved calibration/validation certifications
which verifies the integrity of hardware and ATE software as it relates to all
parameters under test, their specification limits, and resultant input/output
values.
5.0
GENERAL SUPPLIER RESPONSIBILITIES
5.1 Purchase Orders for Testing
Should the supplier decide to perform all or part of
these test requirements at an outside contracted laboratory, GDLS Quality Test
will be notified and purchase order number(s) will be provided. The purchase
order with the selected laboratory shall contain this document and any other
pertinent GDLS contractual requirements to include government surveillance,
when applicable, as part of its contractual language.
5.2 Responsibility for Technical Requirements
The supplier is responsible to provide the laboratory
with all the technical documentation required to perform the test, including
but not limited to the test plan, drawings, specifications, QAPs, QARs,
Engineering Change Proposals (ECP's), Change Requests (CR's), waivers and/or
deviations.
5.3 Laboratory Technical Support by Supplier
The supplier shall support these tests as required at
any test facility utilized for these tests. The selection of an independent
laboratory by GDLS does not relieve the supplier of any of its responsibility
for his product's performance during these tests.
5.4 Failure Analysis
The supplier has full responsibility for any failure
analysis required on his components that fail tests.
6.0
TEST SAMPLE
6.1 Sample Selection
The local Government representative or GDLS will
select the sample to be tested. The test samples will be selected from the
first ten (10) production units manufactured unless otherwise specified by the
GDLS purchase order or by Quality Test. Once the samples are selected for
testing, no repair, adjustment, or modification is permitted without GDLS
approval.
6.2 First Article Inspection (F.A.I.)
A First Article Inspection must be successfully
completed per GDLS QCS 83-4 prior to the start of F.A.T., unless otherwise
authorized by GDLS Quality Test. The F.A.I. samples will be used for F.A.T.
unless direction has been received from GDLS in writing.
6.3 Disposition of Test Sample
Samples subjected to a F.A.T. are not usable as
production hardware. They must be permanently identified (paint, stripe, etc.)
and tagged "DO NOT USE". The supplier shall retain the tested
hardware until after the test report approval and production contract
completion, then request disposition in writing from GDLS. This hardware may
not be disposed of unless so directed by GDLS.
6.3.1 Mini-F.A.T
If a "MINI F.A.T." is performed, GDLS
Quality Test will provide sample disposition to the supplier in writing.
7.0
TEST SCHEDULE AND START NOTIFICATION
7.1 Test Schedule
The schedule for performance of F.A.T. stated in the
purchase order shall be followed unless otherwise approved by the GDLS Quality
Test department. This schedule is based on the product delivery schedule and
testing requirements specified in the product Technical Data Package (T.D.P.).
7.2 Start Notification
The supplier and/or the laboratory performing the
testing must notify the GDLS Quality Test Department a minimum of one (1) week
prior to start of test.
8.0
TEST MONITORING
8.1 Visiting
GDLS and the Government reserve the right to visit the
supplier's facility and/or test laboratory to monitor all or part of the required
First Article Tests.
8.2 Review of testing
Monitoring shall include, but not be limited to,
reviewing test set-ups, monitoring the conductance of the test and review
of/participation in failure analysis activities.
9.0
TEST INCIDENTS/FAILURES
9.1 Definitions of Test Incidents/Failures
A test incident/failure shall be deemed to have
occurred when it is noted that the test unit(s) do not conform within the
specified limits of the QAR, QAP, or specification requirements, or it is
observed that physical damage or deformation has occurred as a result of
testing or other pre-test activities. GDLS reserves the right for final
determination as to the occurrence of a test incident/failure.
9.2 Test Incident/Failure Notification
All incident/failures must be reported by telephone
within 24 hours (1 working day) to GDLS Quality Test Department by the supplier
and/or supplier's laboratory. Point of contact is included within the component
test plan.
The telephone notification must be followed by written
notification within 48 hours (2 working days).
9.3 Test/Hardware Disposition
After an incident/failure, the laboratory shall not
continue testing, disassemble the test set-up and/or sample without GDLS
Quality Test authorization. Phone contact must be maintained with the GDLS
Quality Test Department for failure analysis and/or test restart.
9.4 Flash Report
A copy of the GDLS
"Flash Report", initiated by Quality Test, will be forwarded to the
supplier, reporting the status of the test incident, its effect on
production hardware shipments as well as direction for failure analysis
and retest/restart instructions as they become known. (See Attachment A FLOW CHARTS FOR
SUPPLIER RESPONSIBILITY FOLLOWING A TEST INCIDENT/FAILURE )
9.5 Supplier Failure Analysis
The supplier must submit a written failure analysis
report outlining root cause, proposed corrective action and verification tests within
two weeks of GDLS authorization to proceed with the failure analysis. The
report format is at the supplier's option. This report requires GDLS Quality
Test approval prior to Flash Report closeout,
9.5.1 During the failure analysis process, GDLS
reserves the right to review/audit the supplier's facilities used in the
manufacture/assembly of the components under test.
9.5.2 Failure Analysis Method and Location
GDLS reserves the right to select the method and
location of failure analysis.
9.5.3 Supplier Responsibility
The supplier shall be responsible for all
incident/failure close out actions, re-inspection, and retest when such test
failure is deemed to be the supplier’s responsibility (all activities that are
non-T.D.P. related unless the supplier has control of the T.D.P.). These
responsibilities will include, but not limited to:
A. Test facility charges (i.e.. additional test,
retest, etc.)
B. Implementation of corrective action.
C. Replacement of test samples if required.
D. GDLS failure analysis on repeat test
failures occurring after corrective action incorporation (i.e.. travel
expenses, man-hours, etc.)
10.0
FINAL TEST REPORT
10.1 Report Schedule
Test report preparation and data
collection/organization must be concurrent with testing. Unless otherwise
directed by GDLS Quality Test, two copies of the final test report is to be
supplied to the GDLS Quality Test Department within fourteen (14) days after
test completion.
10.2 Test Report Requirements
The
test report must be in accordance with MIL-HBK-831 (See attachment
"B" TEST REPORT PREPARATION, CHECK LIST
GUIDE) and include the following
information:
A. Completed Test
Report Configuration Summary Sheet (see attachment "B"TEST REPORT PREPARATION,
CHECK LIST GUIDE),
which identifies the revision level of the hardware and technical data
package utilized for the test.
B. Identification of the lot represented by the test
when the FAT is utilized to satisfy a Control Test.
C. List of test equipment utilized for all testing,
including manufacturer/model, range, accuracy and calibration dates (last and
next), as applicable.
D. Specific data to document unit (test sample)
performance before, during and after environmental exposure, where required.
Actual data, which demonstrates conformance to the technical data package
values and tolerances, is required. Recordings of "pass/fail" or
"OK" without actual data are not acceptable, unless otherwise
authorized by GDLS Quality Test (reference 4.3.2.3).
E. Specific data to document and demonstrate
environmental exposure in accordance with the technical data package
requirements and tolerances.
1. Temperature/humidity environments - A legible,
reproducible record (i.e., circular chart, strip chart, data logger recording)
of time versus temperature for temperature environments, and time versus
temperature and relative humidity level for humidity testing. Charts,
recordings shall be annotated with the part name/number, date of test, point at
which storage/operational tests start and complete, explanation of
temperature/humidity profile anomalies and signature or stamp of test
personnel.
2. Vibration Testing - Legible, reproducible
logarithmic plots (i.e., "x-y" plotter or computer generated) of
acceleration versus frequency, recorded from the input accelerometer, for at
least one sweep in each axis (i.e., 5-500-5 hertz).
3. Shock Testing - Legible, reproducible recordings
(photographs or computer generated plots) of calibration pulses and actual test
sample pulses. Recordings of test sample pulses for one drop in each direction
of each axis must be included in the report. The recordings must be of
sufficient size and resolution to demonstrate compliance with the specified
shock pulse tolerance envelope.
4. Salt Fog, chemical exposure, fungus, cleaning
spray, sand and dust environments - The report shall contain sufficient detail
to determine compliance with the specification requirements and the test levels
and methods specified. When certification in lieu of an actual fungus test is
permitted, the certification shall be supported by a previous fungus test
performed on the same configuration part or by certification from component
manufacturers using natural or synthetic materials.
F. Flash Reports, Failure Analysis reports and
pertinent test program correspondence, as applicable.
G. A legible copy of the Ordnance drawing and
equipment specification (i.e., Product Fabrication Specification, QAR/QAP, Military
Standard) for the assembly tested. Also, legible copies of all applicable
(subsequent) change documentation referenced in the purchase order (i.e.,
ECP's, M1A2 CR's, waivers, deviations).
H. A section/appendix for First Article Inspection
documentation. This documentation shall include the GDLS Quality Material
Report (QMR), the First Article Inspection Report (FAIR) form QCS-16 (including
checklists) and any certifications required by the equipment specification.
10.3 Test Report Approval
GDLS Quality Test will approve or comment to the
report content in writing. Upon agreement of the report content by the
supplier/test laboratory and GDLS, GDLS will approve or submit the report for
government approval, as appropriate. If government approval is required, formal
approval should be forthcoming 30 days after receipt by the government.
10.4 Test Data Retention
Test data and records of the test performed by the
supplier (laboratories) and the complete project file including all
documentation shall be kept complete and available to GDLS and the Government
for a period of five (5) years following the completion of the test program.
11.
INVOICE PAYMENT
11.1 Progress Payments. Progress payments for
testing or hardware shipments may be withheld for undue delays, such as:
A) Failure to start or complete testing per purchase
order schedule.
B) Overdue failure analysis response beyond 2 weeks.
C) Overdue report submission or revision.
11.2 Final Invoice Payments
No invoices for First Article Test will be approved
for payment until GDLS approves or receives final Government approval of the
F.A.A. Invoices for First Article Tests must be submitted separately from other
invoice costs.
12.0
TEST REQUIREMENT FULFILLMENT BY REPRESENTATIVE PARTS
12.1 Identification of a Family of Parts
If the supplier produces more than one type of
component which is subject to the same specification (i.e., wiring harness
assemblies, tubes, fittings, etc.) and the manufacturing and assembly processes
are similar for all types, then the requirement for component First Article may
be satisfied on each type by subjecting one representative type to the required
testing. The Government and GDLS reserves the right to select the type by
part number, which shall be tested.
12.2 Representative Part Identification
The purchase order will designate parts that are
represented by the representative part number. The test report for the tested
part number shall also show those part numbers that it represents as defined by
the purchase order. Any flash reports, waivers/deviations, corrective action
reports, etc. shall reference those parts that were represented.
12.3 Test Failure on Representative Part
Any test failure on the representative type shall be
considered to be a failure on all other types unless evidence, satisfactory to
GDLS and the Government, is provided by the vendor that the failure is unique
to the type tested.
13.0
CHANGE TO COMPONENT DESIGN, MATERIALS, MANUFACTURING PROCESS OR
MANUFACTURING LOCATION AFTER FAT APPROVAL
13.1 Hardware and/or Process Changes
Notwithstanding any other contractual requirements, if
after the acceptance of the first production item, which by specification, QAR,
or QAP requires First Article Approval, the supplier or his subcontractor(s)
elects to change the design (if the supplier/subcontractor or his
subcontractor(s) has design control of the item), materials, the manufacturing
or assembly process, or the source of supply, the supplier shall perform, at
the supplier's expense, another F.A.I. and F.A.T. in accordance with the
applicable specifications, QAR or QAP prior to GDLS/Government acceptance of any
items containing the new components. The supplier shall transmit all changes to
GDLS with sufficient lead-time to allow for completion of F.A.A. prior to
implementation so as not to adversely impact production deliveries. Information
shall include reasons/rational for change and results of any testing conducted
to validate performance of change to the TDP.
13.2 Relocation of Manufacturing Site
The supplier (subcontractor) or his subcontractor(s)
may decide that their manufacturing site must be relocated. A location change
notice must be submitted in writing with an explanation of the changes and the
supplier's recommendation for F.A.A. re-testing that may be required. GDLS will
inform the supplier, in writing, of their decision on F.A.A. testing required
by the change. After agreement with GDLS, the supplier may then make the
change.
13.2.1 New Site Audit
The location change may necessitate an audit from GDLS
personnel. The supplier may have to perform GDLS designated acceptance and/or
F.A.A. testing to verify that the location change has not affected his product
as specified by the technical documentation.
13.3 Retest Cost
The costs associated with any re-tests required as a
result of any of the aforementioned changes and all associated costs and time
required by GDLS personnel to verify/approve these test shall be borne by the
suppliers (subcontractor) or their supplier / subcontractors.
13.4 Hardware Shipments
If any of the aforementioned changes are made,
hardware cannot be shipped prior to F.A.A. completion and approval unless
authorized in writing by GDLS.
13.5 Request for Waiver of Retest
The supplier may request a waiver of the new First
Article Approval or of specific test requirements. The request shall provide a
detailed technical explanation as to why the change does not affect the
performance and reliability of the component or why reduced scope testing is
sufficient (e.g.; F.A.I., control test, high & low temperature only, etc.).
The request must be submitted in a timely manner, so that production or
delivery delays will not occur if GDLS or the Government disapproves the
waiver.

QCS-4
AUGUST 2001
ATTACHMENT B
TEST REPORT PREPARATION EVALUATION PER MIL-HBK-831 GUIDE
PART
NO.
___________________ PART NAME _______________________
TEST
REPORT NO.
_________________________
Note: Each report shall have, as a
minimum, each of the elements as listed below
DETAIL REQUIREMENTS (5.0 OF
MIL-HBK-831)
Format (5.1)
Paper (5.2)
Pagination (5.3)
Page Size (5.3.1)
Margins (5.3.1.1)
Margins (5.3.1.1)
Numbering (5.3.1.2)
Binding (5.3.1.3)
Illustration (5.4)
Color Differentiation
(5.4.1)
Abbreviations (5.5)
REQUIRED ELEMENTS (5.6)
Title Page & Cover
(5.6.1)
Tabular Summary Sheet
(5.6.2)
Classified Reports
(5.6.3.2)
Table of Contents (5.6.4)
Reason for Test (5.6.5)
Description of Test
Samples (5.6.6)
Disposition of Test
Specimens (5.6.7)
Narrative Abstract,
Conclusions & Recommendations (5.6.8)
References (5.6.9)
MAIN BODY OF REPORT (5.6.10)
Factual Data (5.6.10.1)
Description of Test
Apparatus (5.6.10.1.1)
Test Procedure
(5.6.10.1.2)
Results of test summations
and analyses (5.6.10.1.3)
Test Data (5.6.10.1.4)
Test Apparatus Calibration
Data
List of all Failure
Incidents, Failure Analysis, & Corrective Action
Permanent Location of Test
Files (Five Years)